Sort:  

Ouch! That has got to sting.

Don't the publications undergo peer review? That is frustrating and time-wasting venture for those that lost their funding as a result of the publication.

Well, peer-review doesn't necessarily spot everything. Their R values were actually pretty good, it was really bad luck.

Ok. That was an unfortunate turn of event.

Peer review just means they make sure everything checks out at a somewhat superficial level. That is why Reproducibility is the gold standard of evidence.